| 1969 | DOUGLAS J MACK | |
| 1972 | JAMES M KERR, JR | CHARLES VEADER |
| 1976 | ANDY MAHONEY | WILLIAM A SIMINOFF |
| 1979 | WILLIAM BACHE | EDWIN A BALDWIN III |
| 1981 | RICHARD SHARPTON | |
| 1983 | HUGH D. NEWMAN, III | SEAN REGAN (note: moved as Life Scout - awarded Eagle in Wisconsin) |
| 1984 | DAMON OWENS | |
| 1985 | ZANE VELLA | |
| 1986 | KEVIN M. NEWMAN | |
| 1987 | CHRISTOPHER AMBROSE | BRETT HEWITT |
| 1989 | DAVID (SCOTT) THOMPSON |
| 1990 | DENNIS CALLEN | |
| 1991 | AARON LOHRMANN | |
| 1992 | DAVID GILL | SCOTT BEIL |
| 1992 | MICHAEL SCHERR | |
| 1993 | ADAM MINKOW | LON GERSTEN |
| 1993 | GEOFFREY GERSTEN | MICHAEL JUNG |
| 1994 | KYLE M. NEWMAN | |
| 1995 | SHANE YOUNG | |
| 1996 | COLIN NEWMAN | |
| 1998 | JONATHAN DEISHER | WALTER PRICE |
| 1998 | MICHAEL WHELPLEY | |
| 1999 | SEAN McDONOUGH |
| 2000 | MARK BREWSTER | WILLIAM DIETZ |
| 2000 | RYAN FRANKENBUSH | |
| 2001 | MICHAEL LOOBY | |
| 2002 | THOMAS "T.C." GREGO | |
| 2003 | MICHAEL TURNER | MICHAEL FOLEY |
| 2004 | ROBERT SKULA | STEVEN SPURR |
| 2004 | NICHOLAS EARL | GREGORY DIETZ |
| 2005 | GRANT LeVALLEY | CHRISTOPHER MURPHY |
| 2005 | SCOT SORENSEN | ANDREW JUNG |
| 2006 | JASON HUNT (note: moved as Star Scout - awarded Eagle in Kentucky) | WILLIAM PFAFF |
| 2006 | CHRISTOPHER ANELLI | MICHAEL LAMM |
| 2008 | ANTHONY GREGO | ERIC DULTZ |
| 2008 | DAN TURNEY | STEPHEN ANTONEK |
| 2008 | CHRISTOPHER BONNER | BRIAN STELLINGWERF |
| 2009 | NICHOLAS ERDENBERGER | NOAH ROSS |
| 2010 | GREG JOHNSEN | |
| 2011 | CHRISTOPHER BATE |